Claim numbers for our carriers. Erie 1 (800) 362-6541 Progressive 1 (800) 925-2886 United Ohio/Ohio Mutual Ins. Grp  1 (888) 488-3223 Lightning Rod/Western Reserve Grp 1 (800) 362-0426 Sandy & Beaver Ins. 1 (800) 421-4693 Dairyland Insurance 1 (800)532-2525 Sanor Insurance 1 (888)728-9114 Foremost 1 (800) 527-3905